Friday, July 24, 2009

Global Pentecostalism: The New Face of Christian Social Engagement

Miller and Yamamori travel throughout the world to compile the current volume offering a portrait of Pentecostalism, a movement of global proportion and of the highest growth rate throughout Asia, Africa, and Latin America. Tracing its roots back to the Pentecost in the second chapter of Acts in the Bible, the modern day phenomena of its re-emergence is attributed to: Charles F. Parham from Bethel Bible School in Topeka, Kansas on January 1, 1901; William J. Seymour in Los Angeles in 1906. Current estimate by World Encyclopedia of Christianity assigns approximately twenty-five percent to fit the description of the Pentecostal.

The diverse expressions in the wide spectrum of Pentecostalism defy the associated traditional stereotypes such as: 1) Ecstatic "slayings in the spirit," required glossolalia or ostentatious, sensationalistic displays of healing; 2) The exclusive background of its adherents as being of uneducated, marginalized, lower socio-economic status; and with 3) such highly spiritualized theology of expected, imminent parousia that hyper-focuses on the other-worldly without regard for the concerns in concrete affairs in the domestic or social realms. These characteristic remain to a certain degree, but Pentecostalism can bee seen as a movement that is highly adaptive to the rapidly changing and widely diverse milieu of its influence. Its growth is attributed to its counteractive effect to anomie and resultant degradation of culture, society, family, and the individual. Secondly, worship which takes its shape both in the fervent expressions of love towards God both musically and otherwise; the practice of love of neighbors as well as the aspects of miraculous healings that are of high importance. The host cultures of the movement that espouses an animistic worldview see a seamless correspondence that is not interrupted by the post-enlightenment disregard for the supernatural. Pentecostalism stands as a forceful opposition or welcome mediation against a static, mechanical, modern worlview and a fragmented, isolated postmodern world view in an organic extension of "familial" body of believers under a developed, praxiological pneumatology- a specialized engagement with the Holy Spirit.

One of the main features of Pentecostalism is that of a marked progressivism. While holiness stands at the center of what is to be taught and guarded, social activism and development of lower economic regions stand as equally important aspects of outreach and a holistic ministry. An eight-fold aspects of these are: 1) Mercy Ministries, 2) Emergency services, 3) Education, 4) Counseling services, 5) Medical assistance, 6) economic development, 7) the arts, 8) policy change. (42-43) These appear as assistance rather than development at an initial glance, but the objective is not temporary solutions rather, a long range development of a community for it to become self-sustaining. Many of the Petecostal ministstries, due to faith convictions outperform many of the nongovernmental organizations in meeting problems such as prostitution in Thailand, which called for not to merely purchase the freedom for the girls which only fueled the trade, aggravating the problem; but to take radical measures such as unionization of sex-workers to give them more power over their circumstances as before. The church in so many parts of the world such as Nairobi, Kenya, Calcutta, has a direct effect on social welfare, so much so that they work in partnership with the NGOs and the government. "Religious ideas never stand alone; they are always influenced by their social location, including the character of the organization that is promulgating them."(53) In praxis, pentecostalism moves with the assumption that the spritual dimension of life is not divorced from the necessities of the physical dimension; which fosters a ministry that would be characteristically described as holistic.

Another remarkable strength of the Pentacostalist movement is its attractiveness to the youth and the manifold ways by which their needs are met. Being that Pentacostals are already engaged in social welfare, the necessities of the children and youth are at the forefront of their programs. This is especially the case in the impoverished areas, Pentecostals with a variety of very creative programs target orphans and at-risk children with survival distress such as AIDS. In various parts of Africa, such as Uganda and Kenya, the shape of childrens ministries are more explicitly committed and long-term, such as make-shift households with both a mother figure that nurtures them, as well as a father figure who mentors the children and the youth. Same is the case for the street children in urban India, where the Christian population is a miniscule minority (3 percent comprised of Catholics and Protestants). In the case of Calcutta, the two-fold focus in the social ministry for the young (Assemblies of God) is heavily invested in education and health services. Christian values as espoused by ministry praxis, is recognized by the young people as valuable. In Caracas, Venezuela for instance, the young people express relief and comfort in the safety of the structure that Sister Marlena provided for them; youth from environments that are otherwise plagued with drugs, alcoholism, sexual abuse, witchcraft among many other disorderly social elements. In the case of the youth community led by Sister Marlena, she provides for the youth in contact with her 1) a maternal figure that imparts discipline; 2) a small worshipping community that functions like an extended family; 3) an encounter with Jesus and the Holy Spirit; 4) channeling of youthful vitality into worship; 5) upward social mobility; 6) testmony of Sister Marlena herself.

The fourth chapter of this book, which outlines an impressive catalog of social transformation is indicative of the sustained social relevance of Pentecostal spirituality. To mention a few, St. Stephens Society, a network of treatment houses for heroin addicts incorporates worship as a central part of its rehabilitation program. Unconditional love is offered as a theoretical explanation on why it sees successes, such as a marked absence of violent withdrawals. The psychological pain that had led them to use the drug in the first place, is countered with God's love as the powerful antidote. In similar ways, the manifold ministries of the Pentecostal movement targets the clinical population in mental health and prisons, AIDS orphans, and small church-operated clinics that acknowledge the healing hands of God which arrive both supernaturally, as well as through medical therapies. Prostitution is also addressed, where rescue missions to women who have been lured by deceptive recruiting agents in rural areas surrounding Bangkok, promising vague positions of employment at restaurants or as housemaids are systematically brainwashed and submitted into turning tricks. An alternative employment is arranged through a deep commitment, in such enterprises as fisheries. The commitment to social transformation, while still under the theological questions of the imminent parousia of Christ is nevertheless carried on by progressive Pentecostals who engage wholly, in issues of economy and politics not just at the margins but very much as active participants who will not shy away from high profile protests such as demonstrations against the corrupt regime of Ferdinand Marcos back in the 1980's as well as micro-loan system for economically troubled areas, taking from the past successes of countries like Bangladesh.

Worship is still the focal point of what energizes the believer's community. In the case of Pentecostals, music and dancing, the psychological catharsis of a vibrant worship is instrumental in the meaningful connection to God. A typical worship session includes the spontaneity as well as the more subdued and reflective invitation that may facilitate an ambience that ushers the participants into a space of deep connection to the Holy Spirit. While the chapter on worship dabbles a bit into the religious and social/anthropolgical theories of Emile Durkheim, the experience of "something more" than the participants in the worship atmosphere is not easily explained as merely a phenomena that is of an emergent nature from a collective activity. Pentecostal theology features a worship theology that does not dissociate the mind and body, as some worship may be perceived to be overtly sensuous or ecstatic- dancing, as it is, is deemed inappropriate still in many denominations of non-charismatic traditions. While vocal critics may rouse issue out of its seemingly primitive expressions, the more correct evaluation of Pentecostalism may be, that its an expression of the deeper parts of our primal spirituality, which is consistent with biblical spirituality that is not adulterated with exessive rationalism and reductive functionalism of human philosophies. Overt physical expressions of faith such as raising of hands, crying out to God, glossolalia, are authentic and not for the sake of some pious display. And being that this is often done during corporate worship, there is the bolstering of a collective experience. As for glossolalia, it is specifically mentioned that it is a private gift of the spirit, which defies conventional assumptions as to how some charismatics may insist on its gift as a sure fire sign of salvation. This emphasis, according to Miller and Yamamori, is decidedly absent. It is also interesting to note, that Pentecostals lean towards the more literal interpretation of the Bible. Which comes, to the issues of spiritual gifting such as the gift of healing. Direct experience of both receiving and facilitating healing informs the theology that remains consistent with the healing narratives of the New Testament. Another practice and phenomena in the Pentecostal churches is deliverance ministries as well as its flipside, the possesion or "slayings" by the Holy Spirit. While to outsiders these practices may seem straght weird, the Pentecostal theology conserves much of the ideas of the supernatural which are expressed in praxis. The remarkable thing is that there is apparent efficacy of these beliefs, up to the point of testimonies that frequent, people being raised from the dead.

Upward social movement and individual improvement of economic conditions is the general trend in the Pentecostal movement, and as of late the middle class have been largely attracted to it. The cause of the trend is obvious and clearly outlined, there is a significant connection between the acquired discipline of worship, and the sustentance of gratitude that transforms lives from a destructive or at least non-constructive patterns into one that leans towards Protestant work ethics, which compliments ideals of capitalism. Many who in former lives, lived in poverty, squandering what little they earn, upon conversion experience a dramatic upshift, which has surplus income reintroduced to their mode of production, thereby fostering growth and financial independence. Prosperity gospel is also a minor feature of the Pentecostals and while at its worst they feature a blind-sided, even manipulative tendencies to exploit those who are already poor, ill, and suffering, at its best there are actual advice regarding family planning, budgeting and lifestyle change. With a strong belief that all people are created equal, and that in God's eyes each person has his or her value, the strong democratic tendencies stand at odds with the hierarchical views such as the Hindu caste system.

Empowering the laity is also a major feature of the strengnths of contemporary Pentecostalism. Pastoral leadership is characterized as fairly authoritarian, with an overwhelming majority male, with an understanding that they are the visionaries for the church, it is also a trend for charismatic preachers to start-up a church and then to leave it to the leadership of the people. The church government in this way, is quite "flat" and what continues the organic nature of ministry is the existence of cell groups that grow through mitosis (when it gets larger, it divides). Theological education is emphasized by some of the Pentecostals who seek sophistication from their pastors but widely regarded as something that can potentially take away from the ministry than be helpful to it. Pentecostalism is one of the fastest growing movements because of the successes in church planting and evangelism that meets social needs. Even in the mission fields there is the resistance of depending on foreign money, as self-sustenance is highly sought after in the beginning of any new churches. This inhibits any tendencies of colonialism, or attitudes of paternalism. Miller and Yamamori offers a fairly secular vantage point upon which to explain the wildly successful growth of Pentecostalism. In spite of the remarkably conservative underpinnings, such as the conspicuous absence of women in the pulpit ministry, is the egalitarian representations in the initiative of women in the ministry, and much of the outdated and legalistic obsessions with tradition that has in the past hindered worship, is now from a marketing point of view, in the realm of the Pentecostals, resolved and keeping relevance with the fast-paced change of our world.

In the concluding chapter, the present movement of Pentecostalism is marked as "progressive," in its holistic understanding of Christianity in social engagement, as well as the incorporation of a multifaceted dynamic elements in worship, such as music and the arts. "projects that engage issues at a systemic level are the leading edge of Progressive Pentecostalism." (213) The organic tendencies of Pentecostalism in its operations are fundamentally different with that of liberation theology, which focuses on the social conflict theories espoused by its Marxist origins. So the process of change is more akin to a quiet revolution than "frontal assault," making social change less conflictive and about dismantling existing institutions but rather, offering an alternative that proves to be a better option for engagement. The future of Pentecostalism is not certain, as it is evaluated by Miller and Yamamori as a "renewal movement," nevertheless the Holy Spirit as the impetus for dynamic, energetic worship which is paired with socially relevant ministry praxis, is promising.

Friday, July 3, 2009

An Introduction to Ecclesiology: Ecumenical, Historical, & Global Perspectives

Dr. K. summarizes for us rather elegantly, the distinctive points of emphasis of the eastern (orthodox) ecclesiology, which are: of a trinitarian view (according to Tsirpanlis) where the Father and son are always involved in the activities of the spirit; a mystical and yet concrete pneumatology; gradual, diachronic sanctification/deification (becoming "like" God), free will discussed in terms of a synergistic "cooperation" between the human and divine; not in mutually exclusive categories of merit and grace. The church, is seen as an organic icon of the Trinity- in its expression of both unity and diversity. Soteriology is collective, "We know that when any of us falls, he falls alone; but no one is saved alone. he is saved in the Church, as a member of it and in union with all its other members."(Ware, Orthodox Church, p.240)

In his exposition of the Roman Catholic ecclesiology, Dr. K. relays the significance of the Lumen Gentium as one of its most important recent documents: "Perhaps the most important development of Vatican II was the replacement of the old societas perfecta, institutional-hierarchic ecclesiology with the dynamic 'people of God' notion in which the church is seen first of all as a pilgrim people on the way to the heavenly city.

In Lutheran ecclesiology, the tension of simul justus et peccator is outlined as what shapes the doctrine of the church community of Luther's soteriology. The adherence to Scripture, and the tenets therein, of the priesthood of all believers, and the imagery of the church as a sanctuary for the "incurably sick" is held as theological basis for caring the neighbor as Christ cares.

Reformed ecclesiology sees more of a covenantal language, with Calvin's distinction of the "Church Visible" versus the "Church Invisible," placing an emphasis on the adherence to the visible church and the belief therein as an aspect of sacramentality that honors God in reverence to one another. Faith was central to the sacraments, the efficacy is continued from Luther's tradition, on faith alone.

Chapter 5 delves into Free Church Ecclesiologies, which stress the fellowship of believers, spirit of ecumenicity, radical reformation, unmediated access to God, and affirmation of the gifts of individuals in a priesthood of all believers. "Holy living has always been of great concern to the ethically oriented mentality of the Free churches. The Anabaptist churches have had 'the ban,' by means of which church members could be excluded from the congregation." (67)

In Chapter 6, Pentecostal/Charismatic ecclesiology is discussed, with an aspect of dynamicity to highlight its features, with the experiential aspect of God's supernatural mystery being central to the worship, which is "another way of saying 'presence of God.'" (71) It is however, rather obscurantist to say the least, to try to define "pentecostal" or "charismatic" as a fully developed ecclesiology. These have shared tendencies to emphasize the Holy Spirit and a more pragmatic pneumatology; participatory nature in worship; empowerment of the laity; importance of the local church; experience of charismatic actions of God; restoration of 'experiential' apostolicty to the whole church; and seamless indigenization to host cultures.

The next movement is one of ecumenical ecclesiologies, which addresses the historically divisive, imposed schisms and their ensuing diversity with the question on ecclesiality for the sake of a unified confession of the one church. The reasoning is simple, "There is one Christ, therefore one church."

In the second section of this book Dr. K. examines some of the contemporary ecclesiologies such as Communion Ecclesiology of John Zizioulas, who taking from the economic Trinity and interactivity of each persons of the Godhead, to be the orthodox expression of the oikonomia Eucharist and communion. "Zizioulas speks of the church as 'instituted' by Christ and 'constituted' by the Spirit."

Although already mentioned earlier, "charismatic" is not an ecclesiology perse, but a characteristic definition of churches that are in the process of renewal. Hans Küng offered some radical tenets that run contrary to those of the Reformation churches: A redefinition of the terms as "invisible" church and an affirmation of the church as is: "A real church made up of real people cannot possibly be invisible. The visible church is the true church, not the false church. Nevertheless, the church is simultaneously visible and invisible." (105 communio santorum- an ecclesiology that stands closer to that of Luther).

In the arena of ecumenics, Wolhart Pannenberg stands as one of the more important ecclesiologists. Noted for a significant contribution to the document, Baptist, Eucharist and Ministry, Pannenberg argues for a unified church for the service of humankind, under the Holy Spirit. "The church then, is the anticipation of the kingdom of God; therefore its essence is constituted by the kingdom, of which it is the sign." (117)

Messianic Ecclesiology may have been the seed that sprouts the emergent movement. Jürgen Moltmann calls for a contextual ecclesiology- drawing from various interests of Pentecostal/Charismatic movements and liberation theology, offering a theology that is "not only contemporary but also contextually relevant." Main features highlighted by Dr. K. are: Christocentrism, egalitarian fellowship (constituted of equal persons with a downplay on hierarchy), invitational "church for others." and a community fostered by the Holy Spirit.

Miroslav Volf takes cues from the ontological Trinity to constitute the church as its image, in what is called "Participatory Ecclesiology." Volf explains church in terms of the presence of the Spirit of Christ- in other words, where He is, so is his church. The church is also, "an assembly of those gathered in Jesus' name." Clustered together in the category of "free churches," the presence of the Holy Spirit as well as the empowerment of the laity are major points of focus.

James McClendon Jr.'s "Baptist Ecclesiology" is perhaps summarized best in the following quote: "In shaping its teaching, the church seeks to be simply church, so that Christians may be a people who find in Christ their center, in the Spirit their communion, in God's reign their rule in life. The convictions that makes such a common life possible fall into three broad, overlapping categories, those that inform Christian living (moral convictions), those that display the substance of Christian faith (doctrinal convictions), and those that open out into Christian vision or world-view (philosophical convictions). (142)

Lesslie Newbigin represents the camp of "Missionary Ecclesiology," where the "understanding of mission is based on the idea that the essential nature of the church is missionary, rather than mission being a task given the church.

In part three of the book, Dr. K. delves into the contextual ecclesiologies of Asia (namely Japan and its emphasis on the non-church: the church that rather is stripped of its institutional aspects) , Latin America and the "Base Ecclesial Communities in Latin America" (175) with its grass roots "bottom-up" approach to church and the necessities of the poor, featuring its liberation theology. And others include: Feminist Churches with the correctives to what is deemed an ongoing gender-biased oppression of the female in the history of the church; African Independent Churches with a certain retention of primal spirituality over and against the Westernization of tribal cultures; and Renewal Ecclesiologies to a full, Global Ecclesiology of the "World Church."

It is a very concise and informative volume that treats a wide range of ecclesiological perspectives, and major points of distinction that in the end do blend together to a few non-negotiable emphasis on God: God of Creation, Jesus Christ and the Holy Spirit, relating to a portion of humanity that identifies itself as set apart, for the love of God to continue through its existence, and practices.

Thursday, July 2, 2009

MC500: Summer Intensive, Summary

It is a super-large course, super-condensed into such a tiny fragment of time. Essentially the summer intensive around this time is comprised of the final balancing of what's left of my academic energy (what amounts to showing up to these morning classes everyday) and ministry: Back at church a myriad things like VBS, Short Term Mission Preparation, KM discipleship, Youth Group, etc... In sum, in my case, was this chronic procrastination for even the daily reflections, leaving it to a sector in my HD of recorded lectures.
Overall Dr. Bolger's methodology for this course seems to offer the panoramic, historical breadth of the nature of church throughout identifiable periods from the very beginning with Jesus. The general trend of change has been, from an "ecclesiality" that was at minimal structure, evolving into an institution, by the time of the Calvinist Reformation having documents such as: Luther's theses and "The Institutes of the Christian Religion." But a question that did come up from one of our post-classroom discussions over lunch with the fellow students was: "What about Mission?" This question reflects back to the title of this course. Church in Mission. It appears that it is Mission in terms of Missio Dei (the sending of God), or perhaps more accurately the Actio Dei (The Action of God) as coined by Karl Barth.
What is at the heart of this course? Are we at this time trying to determine the flow of history so as to come to some understanding on the phenomenological trend of God's involvement in the changing shapes of churches? Social engagement such as community service and mission and witness are categories of examination in which the function of the church within the world at large is examined through history, the chief concerns from the early days that are still alive is this idea of self-propagation. The issue of relevance or perhaps the more biblical "abiding in the True vine" deals with the sprouting of new shoots and new branches that yield their fruits in time. I casually asked Dr. Bolger after all was finished (of the lectures): "So, do you ever get arguments from your oppositions?" (At this point I haven't even yet read "Emerging Churches" so I can't engage in any penetrating dialogue) His answer was: "Yeah, I get hate-mail all the time." (or something along those lines) If I was to reflect on the Emergent Church movement, which seems to allow services that include the music of Enya in this sort of restoration movement of (Celtic, in the case of Enya as a choice for background music) mystical spirituality- the question may be: Is there any danger in blurrying the pagan/Christian divide? Or, is this the final call of what means to be "missional" in the North American spiritual landscape?
If we would be able to identify a point of departure as in the period of Jesus and his disciples and the metamorphosis of the church and the understanding of it through our time, at least what may be readily detectable is if there be any movement that calls for a clear return, to such Apostolic networks as proposed by Eddie Gibbs in Church Next. What may be alarming to some, is this idea of post-Evangelical, post-Christendom movements within the faith. Is this a global movement, or something that is pervasive in Europe and North America? What kind of a picture are we looking at in the next ten years? Glad I took the course, still have a mountain of reading on my plate left over, not to mention sermon preparations, sermon preparations, sermon preparations. Actio Dei, may the good God use these limbs and a mind that has given up any kind of resistance. I surrender all- Jesus, do with me as you will.

MC500: Summer Intensive, Day 9 - Reflection

Free Churches Case Study: Pentecostalism
Renewal movement (also fundamentalism)- similarly, there is a focus on scripture, and a return to our roots scripturally, but fundamentalists would refuse experiences of speaking in tongues, healing, not so full of testimonies, personal experience.

Fundamental / liberal divide in America

The Azusa Street Revival
very strong women leaders, Pentecostals are typically a lot more open to other races in the community. Open to women leadership, when the focus is on giftedness.

Jesus Christ is your savior,
Jesus will baptize you in the Holy Spirit,
our God is a healing God,
and Jesus is coming again (imminent return) [more Premillennial]

Acts 2 - primary reference for the community

Very narrative and enthusiastic preaching, interpretive, pulling from all sorts of different themes both scripture and elsewhere, understanding and expectation where “this is the word of God today for his people”

music, big part of the expression- often spontaneous, spiritual songs given. Very strong understanding that evil is something over the devil, and that we have power over the devil.

baptism, not that different from other Anabaptists, declaration of death with Jesus and being raised with Christ.
Eucharist as well a memorial, not necessarily the presence of God within the bread and the wine; Foot-washing a significant part,

Christian Community – a lot of body life, prayer for one another, prayer for those who are poor, fighting evil in lives, community really sees itself as a gifted community.

Pentecostal churches are often a majority women, provides and advocates for a very stable family life, good number for Pentecostal churches don’t necessarily have equality for women, that in many ways it is good news for women.

A Marxist in So. Am. Brazil, wanted a revolution to do stuff, but if they wanted real social change they needed to study the Pentecostal movement. Where alcoholism and sexual immorality is prevalent and culturally accepted, Pentecostalism is directly against that. (goes into the heart of the urban problems.) So, something noted by both secular and Christian groups. Pentecostals strongly advocate tithing; no smoking, no dancing, no cursing, no alcohol, sort of wanting to be separate from the practices of the world. So Christian missions is continuing what they were doing, ministering the power of the Holy Spirit to those in the outside.

As far as mission goes, very evangelistic about their way of life.
Just in terms of Leadership, the average person is typically very involved in the Pentecostal church. They might have more of a “father” or “mother” role in the community. Some churches in Nigeria that have reached just over a million people. Often the leaders or the founders are called “papa.” You may have a very strong leader in that way, but it doesn’t mean that there aren’t other leaders. They are in many ways functioning like the bishops of the early church. Mostly unpaid.

Wednesday, July 1, 2009

MC500: Summer Intensive, Day 8 - Reflection


Calvin- Was a pastor first of all, all the theological work was written for the church, not the academy. Simony (buying positions in the church), pluralism both problems in the church. Born in Noyon, (to Gerard and Joan) [Erasmus, Seneca, terence, virgil, homer] Penned in 1536, the first draft of the Institutes. the reformation requiring the reform of “letters”. Breaks down the clergy-laity distinction by retaining the deaconship.
The Reformed Church
Goes to U. of Paris at 14, studies law at 19, and pens Institutes by 27. Geneva excited about getting the Roman Catholics out of there, but not too enthusiastic about the reform initiatives of John Calvin: government hires him to be the reader of scripture. Calvin is eventually driven out to where he becomes a pastor in Strausburg for about 3 years.
Church discipline, restrictions, rebuke (which was not present with Luther) order, regulation, morals, holy life very big for Calvin.
Worship
The Word becomes the central part of service, things that build up to the preaching of the Word; Calvin changes the liturgy much more than Luther. What you do is that you sing and pray before the Word of God, you read the particular section of the Bible and then you have thanksgiving after that. The pastor would forgive sins on behalf of the congregation, public prayers, for congregations and leaders, reflecting on the Lord’s prayer, singing psalm and dismissal.
faith emphasized, more specifically, the faith of the recipient.
Eucharist: deeply connected to where Christ is in heaven.
Community
Really wishes to establish the Pastor’s ability to excommunicate. The church was the community, so the townspeople would want to be there.
Mission/Witness
The church is the avenue for those outside of faith to come into faith. In practice, the church is the way for people to know about God. [modality- the preached word]
holy calling (the idea of vocation) as not restricted to the “sacred” but assigned to the “secular.” [initiation of the protestant work ethic]
Consistory
Holiness accountability group
Excommunication had a way back.
Mission in Christendom are usually within the empire.
Leadership and Organization
Pastor is the core of the community; advocacy of elders, team of elders upon whom the administrative duties fell upon. All pastors were teachers, not all teachers were pastors. Elders were more governing, deacons were more serving.